The Magic Pill was still a good documentary despite some of the shortcomings we point out above. The Magic Pill is a great (and different) food documentary that profiles the popular keto and paleo diets that are high-fat and meat-based. The Magic Pill, a 2017 documentary narrated and produced by Evans, advocates for "the paleo way" of living. The Magic Pill dives headfirst into a controversial topic that borders on government conspiracy, but they manage to bring back their message to a personal experience. The Magic Pill’s critics include Dr Michael Gannon, head of the Australian Medical Association, who nominated it as the film/TV production least likely to contribute to public health. If nothing else, it started the conversation and planted the “keto” seed in people’s minds. Film Description. In May 1960, the FDA approved the sale of a pill that arguably would have a greater impact on American culture than any other drug in the nation's history. Keep checking Rotten Tomatoes for updates! Critic Reviews for The Magic Pill. The warning that precedes The Magic Pill – advising viewers to consult with medical professionals – does not absolve the filmmakers of responsibility. It may push viewers to look at what they are eating and they might … The Magic Pill is a character-driven documentary that follows doctors, patients, scientists, chefs, farmers and journalists from around the globe who are combating illness through a … The Magic Pill Documentary Summary. There are no critic reviews yet for The Magic Pill. The Magic Pill is a character-driven documentary that follows doctors, patients, scientists, chefs, farmers and journalists from around the globe who are combating illness through a paradigm shift in eating. Audience Reviews for The Magic Pill. The effects of this diet are both shocking and inspiring!