In the Disney versions, Simba is a young lion who's never hunted a day in his life, and has grown up on a diet of bugs and worms. He is already the king. This is Scar. Shere Khan is the primary antagonist of the 2016 Disney remake of the film The Jungle Book. He is Mufasa’s brother who wants to become the king. While Shere Khan is stronger, Scar is more durable. Both animals fight in similar ways so the outcome is determined by the tiger’s strength. It is actually pretty inventive and very cool. Even IRL tigers are bigger, stronger and faster than lions. This is Scar. Has anybody seen the new Jungle Book movie? Granted Bagheera is smaller and less vicious than Khan but it still shows that Baloo is not good at fighting other carnivores. Shere Khan threatens to take over their hunting territory if the wolves don't give him Mowgli. It is implied that Bagheera's primary motivation for capturing the Fox is to show up Shere Khan after Khan arrogantly rejects Bagheera's offer of help. What is with all of these Disney battle forums? It's awesome. Having been warned by Bagheera, Mowgli attacks Shere Khan and his allies with a burning branch (the mysterious and powerful "red flower" of man) and drives them away. A powerful, suave Bengal tiger, Shere Khan is deeply feared as the most ferocious predator in the jungle. This is Shere Khan. While Shere Khan is stronger, Scar is more durable. Meaning Shere Khan could win if he had the element of surprise, but it's unlikely he'd make it out alive in a head-to-head fight. Shere Khan is a force of nature in that movie. 1967 - Baloo does have a size advantage but he was still nearly killed by Shere Khan who was smaller than him. So, were this a 1v1 encounter between SK and Baloo, I'd give it to SK a solid 7-8/10, but I think Bagheera secures the 'heroes' a win. Akela leaves the pack to become a lone hunter. Sure Shere Khan can shrug off fire, but Scar can survive falling off the edge of Pride Rock in spite of his age. This is Shere Khan. Shere Khan takes this in a pretty one-sided fight. funny seeing all the Shere Khan vs threads) So I may lean slightly towards Bagheera. Fight to Win - Scar Vs Shere Khan Evolved from the sabretooth cats of long ago, today the cats too big to keep as pets, we fear as the vicious predators of the wild. He is already the king. Boomstick: While Shere Khan nearly killed Baloo, Scar would have killed Simba had he not revealed that he was responsible for Mufasa's death. Having been warned by Bagheera, Mowgli attacks Shere Khan and his allies with a burning branch (the mysterious and powerful "red flower" of man) and drives them away. Not that there is anything wrong with that. Shere Khan is the main antagonist of the 2016 Disney live action film The Jungle Book, a remake of the 1967 animated classic. Yeah Louie was just too massive and pretty agile for his size. (great movie though. Akela leaves the pack to become a lone hunter. He is Mufasa’s brother who wants to become the king. Sure Shere Khan can shrug off fire, but Scar can survive falling off the edge of Pride Rock in spite of his age.